Islamic Creed
The Meaning of Umar ibn al-Khattab's Words: What a Good Innovation This Is
Shaykh Abd al-Aziz ibn Abd Allah ibn Baz
Local English rendering of the selected Arabic question and answer. The Arabic source remains authoritative; this is not an official published English edition.
Question
Some people say there are good and bad innovations, citing Umar's words, may Allah be pleased with him, concerning Tarawih: 'What a good innovation this is.' What is your view of this classification?
Answer (English translation)
Answer: Some scholars held that innovations fall into five categories and are subject to the five legal rulings: prohibition, obligation, dislike, recommendation and permissibility. A group held this view. Other scholars rejected it and said that innovations admit of no such classification; rather, they are all misguidance. This is what the leader and imam of the Muslims said: 'Every innovation is misguidance.'
No one has the right to contradict him and say, 'No, not all of it is misguidance.' This is an audacious challenge to the Messenger, peace and blessings be upon him, which is not permissible. The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, 'Every newly introduced matter is an innovation, and every innovation is misguidance.' That is what he said and explained. Neither we nor anyone else may therefore say that some innovation is misguidance and some is not. Rather, all of it is misguidance: everything people introduce into religion is misguidance. The examples cited in support of this classification provide no proof for it.
The things they cite as obligatory innovations, such as adding dots and vowel marks to Quran manuscripts and building mosques, are not innovations. Allah and His Messenger commanded these matters. Allah commanded building mosques and caring for, preserving and reciting the Quran. Whatever assists this is included in the command to preserve it and care for it.
The point is that what they mention is not innovation; it belongs to religion, preserving religion and cooperating in righteousness and mindfulness of Allah.
As for Umar's words, may Allah be pleased with him, when he saw people gathered for Tarawih at his command: during the Prophet's time, peace and blessings be upon him, people prayed individually and in groups. The Prophet gathered them and led them in night prayer for three nights. He then stopped and said, 'I fear that night prayer might be made obligatory upon you.' He was compassionate towards his community, peace and blessings be upon him.
After he died, al-Siddiq, may Allah be pleased with him and grant him His pleasure, was occupied with the apostates, and the Companions were occupied with them as well. When Umar became caliph, he had more time for this, and his caliphate was long. He considered gathering people behind a single imam instead of their praying in separate groups in the mosque. He gathered them behind one imam and instructed Ubayy to lead them. When he went out one night and saw them, he said, 'What a good innovation this is.' He called it an innovation in the linguistic sense, not the religious sense, because in language an innovation is something done without a preceding example.
The meaning is that they had previously prayed in separate groups, without gathering behind one imam. When Umar gathered them, he said, 'What a good innovation,' referring to what he had arranged for them so that they could unite and cooperate in righteousness and mindfulness of Allah. The Messenger had not continued doing it: he did it for three nights and then stopped. This is why Umar said what he did. He meant it linguistically, not in the sense of a religiously introduced practice.
In religious terms it is therefore not an innovation. Rather, it is a Sunnah and an act of devotion practised by the Messenger, peace and blessings be upon him, the rightly guided caliphs Umar and those after him, the Prophet's Companions and the Muslims. The Prophet encouraged it, saying, 'Whoever stands in prayer during Ramadan with faith and seeking reward will have his previous sins forgiven.' He also said, 'Whoever stands in prayer with the imam,' meaning during Ramadan, 'until he finishes will have a whole night's prayer recorded for him.' This indicates that night prayer is prescribed and may have an imam and a congregation. It has nothing to do with innovation.
